Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band album cover by The Beatles featured in a vintage vinyl record subscription box from Nostalgic Groove
Goodbye Yellow Brick Road album cover by Elton John, featured in a curated vintage vinyl record subscription from Nostalgic Groove.
Head Hunters album cover by Herbie Hancock, a landmark jazz-funk release featured in Nostalgic Groove’s curated vintage vinyl collection.
Aretha Franklin’s “I Never Loved a Man the Way I Love You” album cover.  A soul classic featured in Nostalgic Groove’s vintage vinyl collection.

Join our vintage vinyl record club

Monthly deliveries of handpicked vintage records from the 60s, 70s, and 80s matched to your taste.

How it works

  • Step 1: Take the quiz

    Create an account and tell us what music you’re into. It’s quick, easy, and helps us get a feel for your taste.

  • Step 2: We find your record match

    Based on your quiz our curators pick vintage albums we think you'll love. Every pick is selected by a real person, not an algorithm.

  • Step 3: Grow your collection

    We help you build your collection with quality vintage records that are cleaned, sleeved, and ready to spin. Each record is a little reflection of who you are.

Why our record club rocks n' rolls

  • Premium records

    Cleaned, sleeved, and inspected to ensure every vintage vinyl delivers a top-notch listening experience.

  • Free shipping

    Free shipping always because great vinyl records should show up with no extra fees.

  • Flexible memberships

    We keep it simple with monthly record club memberships with no strings attached. Upgrade or cancel at anytime.

  • Handwritten notes

    Each order comes with a note from one of our curators sharing a bit about the record picks.

  • Carefully packed

    We pack each order in sturdy record mailers with inserts to keep your vinyl safe all the way to your turntable.

  • Save vintage records

    We rescue overlooked records and give them a second chance with someone who’ll love them.

Here's what our record club members have to say

Your record club questions answered

Why should I sign up instead of just going to my local record store?

We love record stores and think you should keep supporting yours. Nostalgic Groove is just a different way to build your vinyl collection. We send you quality vintage records that are cleaned, sleeved, and ready to play. Each one is picked based on your taste to help you discover music you might have never found on your own. There is something special about opening each box. A little surprise that keeps it exciting month after month.

What if I don't like the records sent to me?

If this ever happens, we get it. Music is personal. While we encourage joining with an open mind and a sense of discovery but we know not every pick will land. That’s why we offer a 7 day return policy on any record club vinyl. If you’re not feeling it, just send it back and we’ll refund you. To help keep costs low, the return shipping cost will be deducted from the refund.

Do I know what I’m getting each month before it ships?

Nope — and that’s part of the fun. Nostalgic Groove is a personalized vinyl subscription built around surprise and discovery. Your records are handpicked based on your taste, so no two boxes are the same. Every shipment is a chance to hear something new or reconnect with something you forgot you loved.

Can I easily update my music preferences?

Yes. You can edit your music quiz anytime by logging into your account. We’ll use your updated answers to guide future picks, so your record club subscription stays personal and reflects your taste as it grows and changes.

How does shipping and returns work?

We ship every record club order for FREE using sturdy record mailers with protective inserts to keep your vinyl safe. Tracking info is emailed as soon as your order goes out. If we ever miss the mark, you have 7 days to return any record club vinyl. Just send it back in the same condition and we’ll refund you, minus the return shipping cost.

Can I cancel my membership anytime?

Yes. You can cancel your vinyl subscription anytime right from your account page. No pressure and no hassle. If it’s not the right fit or the right time, you’re free to end your record club membership whenever you need to.